Okay wall of text time. Sorry Rover, but I need to to explain why this type of stuff is important to people who may not own a small businesses and don't understand the impact of this type of thing.
I disagree with the site being fine "as is." This isn't from a personal perspective, it's from a business perspective. I very much appreciate this forum and his main one, but there is little question in my mind that things are hard to find on the main website. Sure, it can be "prettied up" with fancy images, but that's way less important than a functional, easy-to-use website. Photos don't make a website better (unless you're a model like Kate Upton...).
Why does Pilkguns need a functional, easy-to-use website? Considering that a major target audience for competition shooting seems to be youth shooting in the U.S., it is essential to have an easy-to-understand website, both for the children and for the parents who have day jobs. They're not going to spend all day figuring out a website's design just to help their kid purchase a gun or pellets. They'll just move on and find someone else who stocks the item, like amazon (yes they stock pellets and cleaning supplies) or another competitor website.
In today's world, a business owner has to have a website that works and is easy to update. We all have real jobs (you know, making money and all that) and I don't know a single business owner that doesn't hate keeping their websites updated (I've been slack about mine, but I intend to change that today.) We all need to collectively suck it up: those updates are critical to retain customer interest. Sure, most of the older crowd knows who Pilkguns is, and the people who run the competition circuits know who pilkguns is, but what about the newer body of people who want to know about competition shooting in the wake of the Olympics?
Like Pilkguns, I am in a low-volume, high-value industry. Each individual sale matters a lot for the bottom line. Referrals are a crucial part of business. For us, the basic process works like this:
1. we have a pool of people who know about us.
2. We have a smaller pool who likes us (the first impression might have been good: somebody talked about their experience with us, or they visited our website and liked it), and
3. an even smaller pool that has grown to trust us (this group is thinking seriously about estate planning and we are near the top of their list, whether due to a recommendation, our website in comparison to others, or other factors such as personal connections.)
That last pool is the one that we get clients from. Part of earning that trust is ensuring that you are competent in the area you state you are, and for better or worse, first impressions are
very important to establishing that trust. Once we get a client, our customers are almost always highly satisfied,
but we have to get that client first! And since the first experience most people will have with Pilkguns is through the website, the website's first impression is critical.
So now that we've established why a good website is important, let's talk about what a good website is. Website design boils down to this: get the user to what they want to find in as few clicks as possible, and make the experience nice and aesthetically pleasing.
Let's take two users of Pilkguns and break down what they have to do to get what they want.
User A wants information about a Steyr LP10. He goes under the drop-down menu of "our products" and select "pistols and gear." This takes him to a smaller page called "Pistol Menu." Out of those options, he clicks "World Class AP." He then has to scroll down to the LP10 entry under Steyr. It has a number of buttons including one that has a list of prices. But here's a problem: A User has NO IDEA that Pilkguns includes a technical section containing blowups and manuals for the LP10. To get to that, he has to go to "our services" then "coaching and info" then "10P files" then click on "Steyr" to access them.
From a design perspective, why not just include a button linking to the 10P Steyr section in the LP10 entry and save that extra effort and clicking? Sure, not everyone needs it, but since serious purchasers of pistols would generally appreciate the ease of accessing sophisticated information without having to stumble on it while looking for other things. Also, that entire list, from our products to the Steyr LP10 could have been accomplished with a single nested drop-down menu. User A clicks once, he is at the Steyr LP10 area. That's the ideal to shoot for.
Now for User B:
User B wants to buy pellets for his air rifle. He's a hobby shooter and doesn't need much more than the basics. He highlights "Our Products" and selects "targets and pellets" (which, by the way, should be reversed since more people will be looking for pellets than targets. I shoot five-ten pellets a target.) He is now at a page that talks about Vogel pellets, but there is nothing about price? Confused, he clicks the link to "price list and buy" at the bottom of the screen, which leads him to the part of the overall price list containing pellets. "Ah! Here we are, finally!" User B thinks. He buys the pellets.
The sale was successful, but it's not all roses. I want you to stop and think about what User B is thinking. This is not a position you want customers to be in. Instead of making his job of buying pellets easier, he has had a difficult time finding them. While the website did its job (it sold pellets and made money), it did not make a good first impression. User B is less likely to come back in the future for larger purchases, such as that new gun he's been saving up for. There are other websites out there that sell the exact same thing that are easier to navigate. Once again, a nested drop-down menu would solve this problem, taking User B directly to a menu that contains ONLY pellet selections. Also, some basic content information explaining the difference between the different diameters of 4.5mm pellets would be helpful to our hobbyist, since he probably has no clue why he would choose a 4.49mm over a 4.50mm.
That sort of stuff doesn't show up in statistics as it's pretty much impossible to track, but it is what drives a small, low-volume high-price business. And this is only a small taste of the insanity involved in web design. I'm not even going to talk about search engine optimization or merchant security. But those are all very important things that can matter a huge deal.
So in summary:
1. Website design matters to people who have not met you before.
2. The website is the most likely place that people who have not met you before will learn about Pilkguns.
3. Like any professional businessman, you should make their experience as smooth and easy as you can so that the new prospective customer likes you. Having an aesthetically pleasing website is a consideration, but planning out how users will access content is critical. Also, make sure you know how to change content to keep with events and set aside time to do so.
4. You should have informational content that is easy to access so that the customer who likes you can learn to trust you.
5. This will drive sales of products and form a long-term relationship with the customer that will bring them back for consumables and repairs.
6. The customer will recommend the website to any friends he has that are involved in air pistol or air rifle. And so the cycle starts over again at #1.